Table of contents
Summary

Stop-loss insurance is a key risk management tool for employers with self-funded health plans. It protects organizations from unexpectedly high medical claims by reimbursing costs that exceed predetermined thresholds, helping HR and finance teams budget more predictably. Understanding stop-loss is essential for employers exploring self-funding because it makes the model more financially stable and sustainable.

Self-funding gives you more control over your health plan and your healthcare spend. It also means your company pays employees' medical claims directly, which raises a question every CFO asks sooner or later: what happens when one claim costs half a million dollars?

That's where stop-loss insurance comes in. Here's how it works, what drives the cost, and what to look for before you sign a policy.

What is stop-loss insurance?

Stop-loss insurance is a policy self-funded employers buy to cap their exposure to large or unexpected health claims. When claims go above a set dollar threshold, called the attachment point, the stop-loss carrier reimburses your plan for the amount above it.

The U.S. Department of Labor describes stop-loss as protection against claims that are "catastrophic or unpredictable in nature," whether that's one person's claims or total claims across the plan.

One detail trips a lot of people up: stop-loss protects the employer. Your plan still pays claims to providers as usual, and the carrier reimburses your plan once claims cross the attachment point. Employees usually never see it.

Why stop-loss insurance matters for self-funded employers

Self-funding is now how most people with employer coverage get their health benefits. According to KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, 71% of covered workers are in self-funded plans, including 85% at firms with 200 or more workers.

Smaller employers are getting there too. KFF found that 38% of covered workers at smaller firms are in level-funded plans, which pair a small self-funded component with stop-loss insurance.

Stop-loss matters because healthcare spending is so concentrated. In 2020, according to data from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality:

  • The top 1% of people accounted for 24.2% of all healthcare spending
  • The top 5% accounted for 52.9%
  • The bottom 50% accounted for just 2.6%

For a 300-person company, that means a handful of employees or dependents can drive most of your claims in a given year. A premature birth, a cancer diagnosis, or an organ transplant can turn a good year into a budget problem fast. Stop-loss keeps one of those events from becoming a financial crisis.

Self-funding with stop-loss is less risky than it sounds

A lot of HR and finance leaders hear "self-funding" and think "more risk." We see it differently.

With a fully insured plan, you might get a renewal that's 15% or 20% higher than last year, with little or no claims data to explain why. That's risk you can't see and can't manage.

With a self-funded plan and the right stop-loss coverage, you know your worst-case cost before the plan year starts. You also get your claims data, so you can see what's driving spend and do something about it.

How does stop-loss insurance work?

Most stop-loss policies have two parts: specific coverage and aggregate coverage. You can buy them separately, but most mid-size employers carry both.

Specific stop-loss

Specific stop-loss (also called individual stop-loss) caps how much your plan pays for any one person in a plan year. That threshold is called the specific deductible.

Say your specific deductible is $100,000 and an employee has $350,000 in claims this year:

  • Your plan pays the first $100,000
  • Your stop-loss carrier reimburses the remaining $250,000

Aggregate stop-loss

Aggregate stop-loss caps your total claims across the whole plan for the year. The aggregate attachment point is set as a percentage above your expected claims. The DOL uses 125% of expected claims as its example.

Say your expected claims are $4 million and your aggregate attachment point is 125%, or $5 million. If total claims come in at $5.6 million, the carrier reimburses the $600,000 above the attachment point.

How specific and aggregate coverage work together

The two layers protect you from different kinds of bad years:

  • One very expensive claim: Specific coverage kicks in when a single person's claims cross the specific deductible.
  • Lots of mid-size claims: Aggregate coverage kicks in when claims across the plan run high, even if nobody hits the specific deductible.

Claims above the specific deductible generally don't count toward your aggregate attachment point, so the two layers don't overlap.

Stop-loss terms every HR leader should know

Two policies with the same deductible can protect you very differently. These terms are where the differences hide, so ask about each one before you sign.

  • Attachment point: The dollar threshold where coverage starts. For specific coverage, it's per person. For aggregate coverage, it's a percentage of expected claims.
  • Contract basis: The window a claim has to be incurred and paid in to be covered. It's written as two numbers:
    • 12/12: Claims must be incurred and paid in the same 12-month policy period. It's the cheapest option, but claims incurred late in the year and paid after it ends aren't covered.
    • 12/15: Covers claims incurred during the 12-month period and paid within 15 months, which gives you a three-month run-out.
    • 15/12: Covers claims incurred in the three months before the policy starts (the run-in) and paid during the policy year. This is common when you're moving from a fully insured plan.
    • Paid contract: Covers claims paid during the policy year, no matter when they were incurred. It's often used at renewal to avoid gaps between policy years.
  • Lasering: When a carrier sets a higher specific deductible for one person with a known high-cost condition. If your specific deductible is $100,000 and one member is lasered at $400,000, your plan carries the first $400,000 of that person's claims.
  • Aggregating specific: An extra layer of claims above the specific deductible that your plan pays before the carrier starts reimbursing. Some employers take one on to lower premiums, but it adds risk.
  • Rate cap: A limit on how much your premium can go up at renewal.
  • No new laser provision: A guarantee that the carrier won't add new lasers at renewal.
  • Terminal liability: Extends coverage for claims paid after the policy ends if you leave self-funding or end the plan.

Your stop-loss contract also has to line up with your plan document and your third-party administrator's claims process. If your plan covers something the stop-loss policy excludes, your company pays the full cost.

How much does stop-loss insurance cost?

There's no standard price for stop-loss. Carriers price each group individually, based on factors like:

  • Your specific deductible: A lower deductible shifts more risk to the carrier, so you'll pay a higher premium.
  • Group size and demographics: Age, gender mix, and location all affect expected claims.
  • Claims history and known large claimants: Ongoing high-cost conditions, like cancer treatment or dialysis, weigh heavily in pricing.
  • Contract basis: More run-in or run-out coverage costs more.
  • Industry: Some industries carry higher expected claims than others.
  • Market conditions: Carriers factor in overall medical cost trends and how their own business is performing.

Picking a deductible comes down to how much risk your company can absorb in a bad year. And the lowest quote can end up costing more once you factor in lasers, exclusions, and weak renewal protections. Compare the full contract alongside the premium.

Who needs stop-loss insurance?

If your health plan is self-funded, you need stop-loss. Only the very largest employers can comfortably absorb a run of multimillion-dollar claims on their own. How you get that coverage depends on how your plan is set up:

  • Traditional self-funded plans: You buy specific and aggregate coverage from a stop-loss carrier, usually through your broker, and work with a TPA to pay claims.
  • Level-funded plans: Stop-loss is built in. You pay a fixed monthly amount that covers expected claims, admin fees, and stop-loss premium. If claims come in low, some plans return part of the surplus.
  • Group captives: Smaller and mid-size employers pool part of their stop-loss risk with other employers. This can stabilize costs and lets members share in the results when claims run well.

How to choose a stop-loss carrier and policy

Here's what to check before you sign:

  1. Match the contract to your plan document. Any benefit your plan covers that the stop-loss policy doesn't is a gap your company pays for.
  2. Check the contract basis against your claims timing. This matters most in your first year of self-funding and any time you switch carriers or TPAs.
  3. Understand disclosure requirements. Carriers ask you to disclose known large claimants when you apply. Incomplete disclosure can lead to denied reimbursements later.
  4. Read the renewal terms. Ask about rate caps and no new laser provisions, and what they cost.
  5. Ask how fast claims are reimbursed. A large claim can strain cash flow. Some carriers offer advance funding, which reimburses the plan before your company pays the claim.
  6. Look at the carrier's financial strength. You want a carrier that will be around and paying claims years from now.

Where your broker fits

Stop-loss is one of the places where an experienced benefits broker earns their keep. A good broker shops the market, compares contract terms beyond the premium, and catches gaps between your stop-loss policy, plan document, and TPA before a claim does. If you're not sure your current coverage would hold up in a bad year, a benefits advisor can walk through it with you.

What to expect at stop-loss renewal

Your stop-loss renewal depends on three things: your own claims experience, any large claimants expected to carry into next year, and conditions in the broader stop-loss market.

If you had a high-cost claimant this year, expect the carrier to respond with a laser, a bigger rate increase, or both. If your stop-loss renewal came in higher than you expected, you're not alone. Here's how to put yourself in a better position:

  • Start early: Begin the conversation with your broker at least four months before your renewal date.
  • Bring your data: Clean, current claims data helps carriers price your group accurately and gives your broker more to negotiate with.
  • Look at more than one lever: Raising your specific deductible, changing contract basis, or adding a rate cap can all change the math.
  • Shop the market: Your current carrier's renewal offer isn't the only option on the table.
Better benefits ahead. Talk to an expert.

Stop-loss insurance FAQ

What risks does medical stop-loss insurance cover?

Medical stop-loss covers two risks: one person's claims going above your specific deductible, and total plan claims going above your aggregate attachment point. Coverage depends on your contract, so check exclusions, lasers, and contract basis.

Does stop-loss insurance pay employees directly?

No. According to the Department of Labor, stop-loss "does not usually guarantee the payment of benefits to plan participants" and instead insures the employer against losses. Your plan pays claims, and the carrier reimburses the plan.

What's the difference between stop-loss insurance and level funding?

Stop-loss is the insurance policy. Level funding is a way to structure a self-funded plan, with stop-loss built in. Level-funded plans bundle expected claims, admin fees, and stop-loss premium into one fixed monthly payment.

When does stop-loss insurance apply?

Specific stop-loss applies once a single person's claims pass your specific deductible during the contract period. Aggregate stop-loss applies at the end of the contract period if total claims pass your aggregate attachment point. Some policies offer monthly aggregate accommodation for cash flow.

Is stop-loss insurance the same as reinsurance?

They're similar, but they cover different buyers. Reinsurance protects insurance companies against large losses. Stop-loss protects self-funded employers. Self-funded plans are governed by ERISA, while stop-loss policies are regulated by states as insurance.

Get stop-loss coverage that holds up in a bad year

Stop-loss is what makes self-funding work. The right policy turns unpredictable risk into a known, manageable cost. The wrong one leaves gaps you won't find until a big claim lands.

Nava's advisors can review your current stop-loss contract, pressure-test it against your claims data, and help you head into renewal with options. Talk to an expert.

Last updated: Nov 05, 2026